Skip to content
2026 Criminal Trialtrial-daytrial-dayShanan BuckinghamJennifer SpragueKevin ReddingtonJustin BrowerNicholas RobertsKatarina StashynEitan NegriElaine RossidirectcrossredirectDay 7 - August 5, 2026Medical witnesses described Clancy's wrist injuries and drug concentrations, with limits on what those findings established. DNA testimony addressed exercise-band mixtures and house stains, while former nanny Elaine Rossi recalled attentive parenting, reported postpartum and sleep difficulties, and no safety concerns during her employment.
← Day 62026 Criminal TrialDay 8 →

Day 7 - August 5, 2026

Injury and Toxicology Testimony, DNA Evidence, and Nanny's Account

Judge William Sullivan
15Proceedings
6Pages
5Witnesses
1,364Lines
Day 7 of 28
Appearing:

Medical witnesses described Clancy's wrist injuries and drug concentrations, with limits on what those findings established. DNA testimony addressed exercise-band mixtures and house stains, while former nanny Elaine Rossi recalled attentive parenting, reported postpartum and sleep difficulties, and no safety concerns during her employment.

Full day summary

Medical witnesses described Lindsay Clancy's injuries and blood testing, followed by DNA evidence and testimony from former nanny Elaine Rossi. Physician assistant Eitan Negri described repairing Clancy's wrist wounds on January 25, 2023. He observed no active bleeding in the previously dressed wounds and used sutures and Steri-Strips. The court admitted four photographs of the repairs. On direct examination, he said the wounds did not extend deeper than subcutaneous tissue; on cross-examination, he described one repaired wound as three centimeters deep and agreed with measurements read from another clinician's note. He acknowledged that Clancy was critically ill and had suffered cardiac arrest, but was not present for that event. He distinguished his continuing management of her care from treatments he did not perform. Former State Police toxicology analyst Nicholas Roberts reported no alcohol and identified benzodiazepines and other medications in Clancy's blood. He explained that several findings could be metabolites of diazepam rather than separately ingested medications. He did not know the specific collection timing or which drugs came from prescriptions. NMS forensic toxicologist Justin Brower described lamotrigine, mirtazapine and trazodone concentrations as therapeutic or consistent with prescribed use. He characterized quetiapine at 1,800 nanograms per milliliter as elevated, depending on dosage, but not necessarily toxic or lethal. Brower lacked actual prescription information and stressed that concentrations alone could not establish Clancy's behavioral or respiratory response. The court admitted the NMS report and later a corrected report. The court admitted four DNA stipulations. The judge read findings concerning a blue exercise band and a basement stain, including Callan Clancy's inclusion as a major contributor to the band-middle profile and Cora Clancy's inclusion in the single-contributor stain profile. Analyst Katarina Stashyn then described yellow- and black-band mixtures and exterior-house stains. She explained that relatedness complicated mixture interpretation, likelihood ratios were not random-match probabilities, and separate inclusionary statistics did not establish that the named individuals were present together. Exterior stains B and D supported Lindsay Clancy's inclusion; stain C and the black-band ends were unsuitable for comparison. The defense declined cross-examination. Rossi described caring primarily for Callan from September to early December 2022. She identified the childcare notebook and a bottle-feeding video admitted into evidence. She recalled Clancy reporting postpartum difficulties, serious sleep problems, medical care and medication, and observed significant weight loss. Rossi described attentive parenting and no safety concerns during her employment. She said Clancy planned to stop nursing because of a new medication, but knew no medication details. On redirect, Rossi said they had not discussed intrusive thoughts or thoughts of self-harm.

Video thumbnail2:18:52
Watch →

3. Justin Brower — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Justin Brower completed his toxicology testimony, describing medication concentrations and limits on interpreting their effects. Cross-examination addressed missing prescription information, and the court admitted laboratory reports before releasing him.

→
Direct
Direct Examination - Justin Brower Justin Brower Shanan Buckingham
186 lines

Brower described mostly therapeutic drug concentrations, compared quetiapine with suicide-case levels, and emphasized limits on inferring individual effects from laboratory results.

Cross
Cross-Examination - Justin Brower Justin Brower Kevin Reddington
90 lines

Brower qualified his drug-level interpretations, acknowledged missing prescription information, and distinguished elevated quetiapine from necessarily toxic levels. The NMS report was admitted as Exhibit 206.

Redirect
Redirect Examination - Justin Brower Justin Brower Shanan Buckingham
13 lines

Brower confirmed authoring a corrected report, which the court admitted without objection.

Highlights

5. Katarina Stashyn — Direct

Katarina Stashyn described DNA results from exercise-band swabs and exterior-house stains, emphasizing limits on interpreting family members' inclusion in mixtures. The defense declined cross-examination.

→
Direct
Direct Examination - Katarina Stashyn Katarina Stashyn Jennifer Sprague
174 lines

Stashyn reported exercise-band and exterior-stain DNA results, emphasizing relatedness, independent inclusion statistics, and limits on identifying contributors to mixtures.

Highlights

6. Elaine Rossi — Direct/Cross/Redirect

Former nanny Elaine Rossi described Lindsay Clancy’s childcare and reported postpartum and sleep difficulties, while saying she observed no change in her interactions with the children and had no concerns about their safety.

→
Direct
Direct Examination - Elaine Rossi Elaine Rossi Shanan Buckingham
315 lines

Nanny Elaine Rossi described Lindsay's reported health difficulties, favorable parenting observations, and the end of her employment. A bottle-feeding video was admitted as Exhibit 213.

Cross
Cross-Examination - Elaine Rossi Elaine Rossi Kevin Reddington
108 lines

Rossi described attentive parenting, appropriate childcare instructions, reported sleep and postpartum difficulties, and observed weight loss, while acknowledging limits on her recollection.

Redirect
Redirect Examination - Elaine Rossi Elaine Rossi Shanan Buckingham
8 lines

Rossi denied discussing intrusive thoughts or self-harm with Clancy.

Procedural
Jury Admonition and Recess Until 9 a.m.
13 lines

Highlights

← Day 62026 Criminal TrialDay 8 →